Articles · Labor

External work and overtime: who has the burden of proving the hours worked by external employees?

Brazil's Superior Labor Court requires employers to prove they could not monitor the hours of external employees. The Supreme Federal Court found the issue is not constitutional, so the rule stands.

Whether an external employee falls under article 62, I, of the Brazilian Labor Code (CLT) depends on proof that the company must produce. That is the position of the Superior Labor Court (TST) in Theme 73 of its repetitive appeals. In October 2026, Brazil's Supreme Federal Court (STF) found that the matter lacks general repercussion (the constitutional-significance threshold the STF requires before it reviews an appeal), which closed the constitutional route for revisiting it.

The exception in article 62, I, of the CLT

Article 62, I, excludes from the working-hours regime employees who perform external activity incompatible with setting a work schedule. Outside that regime, no overtime is owed. The law requires the condition to be recorded in the employee's work card (CTPS) and in the company's employee register.

Performing services away from the company's premises is not enough to qualify. The statutory criterion is that the activity be incompatible with setting a schedule.

The TST thesis

The TST's full court set the thesis in Theme 73. The rapporteur was Justice Aloysio Corrêa da Veiga, and the ruling, issued in March 2025, was unanimous. The thesis reads: “The employer bears the burden of proving the impossibility of controlling the working hours of external work, because it is a fact that bars the worker's right.”

The basis is article 818, II, of the CLT, which assigns to the defendant the burden of proving a fact that bars the plaintiff's right. The employee claims overtime. The company answers that the employee was outside the working-hours regime. The company must prove that answer.

The court added that performing services away from the company's premises does not, by itself, place the employee within the exception. The company must prove that controlling working hours was impossible, whether directly or indirectly.

The appeal to the STF

The appealing company argued that the thesis imposes impossible proof, that of a negative fact, in violation of the right to be heard, the right to a full defense and equality of arms. Justice Guilherme Augusto Caputo Bastos, vice president of the TST, admitted the extraordinary appeal (the appeal to the STF on constitutional grounds) as representative of the dispute and sent it to the Supreme Court in February 2026. A TST search conducted in March 2025 had found 178 appellate rulings and 4,228 single-justice decisions on the subject in the preceding twelve months.

The STF decision

In October 2026, the STF's full court unanimously found that the matter lacks general repercussion. The rapporteur was Justice Edson Fachin. The reasoning is that revisiting the allocation of the burden of proof would require interpreting articles 62, I, and 818, II, of the CLT, which is a question of ordinary legislation, not of the Constitution. The thesis adopted reads: “The dispute over the allocation of the burden of proof regarding the impossibility of controlling the working hours of an employee in external work, for purposes of falling within the exception provided in art. 62, I, of the CLT, is infraconstitutional, and the effects of the absence of general repercussion apply to it.”

The STF did not rule on the merits. It neither upheld nor rejected the TST thesis. It recognized that interpreting the CLT on this point is a matter for the TST, so the TST thesis remains in force.

The rapporteur described the TST's settled understanding in these terms: the exception in article 62, I, applies when controlling working hours is virtually impracticable, not when the employer chooses to forgo that control.

The STF reviews the burden of proof when the question has its own constitutional dimension, as in Themes 1,118, on outsourcing and the Public Administration, and 1,389, on the engagement of self-employed workers and companies as service providers. External work did not fit that category.

Implications for management

The decision does not grant overtime to every external employee. It defines who must prove the exception. If the company does not meet that burden, the exception does not apply, and the employee is subject to the ordinary working-hours regime.

Legal and HR departments should consider the following points:

  • Mapping external positions: identify which employees the company places under article 62, I, and on what grounds.
  • Proof of incompatibility: document, for each position, why the activity does not allow a schedule to be set or controlled.
  • Indirect control: because the TST considers both direct and indirect control, review the management tools used with external teams, such as visit routes, apps, tracking, targets and regular contact.
  • Formal records: check whether the condition appears in the work card and in the employee register.
  • Governance decision: assess, position by position, whether the company will rely on the exception or adopt time recording.

© 2026 Diego Amâncio Dias. Original text. Reproduction is permitted with credit to the source.

← All articles
Contact

Tell us about your operation in Brazil.

A first conversation covers the structure of your Brazilian workforce, the question in front of you and the timeline. Scope and fees are then confirmed in writing before any work begins.

Email
[email protected]
Phone and WhatsApp
+55 11 91090-1402
Languages
English, Portuguese, Spanish