Articles · Union

Can an employer require the ICD code on a sick note? The Brazilian labor court ruling that reignites the debate

Brazil's Superior Labor Court denied damages to a worker whose absence days were deducted because her medical certificate lacked the ICD code required by her collective agreement. Understand the ruling, the data protection and medical rules, and the risk for employers and unions.

On October 14, 2026, the Fifth Panel of Brazil's Superior Labor Court (TST) unanimously held that an employer that requires the ICD code (the International Classification of Diseases code, known in Brazil as CID) on medical certificates under a collective bargaining agreement, and deducts the days covered by certificates without the code, does not owe moral damages unless there is evidence that the diagnosis was exposed. The decision was issued in case no. 0000299-37.2024.5.12.0014, reported by Justice Breno Medeiros, and brings back one of the most frequent questions from workers and HR professionals: may an employer require the ICD code on a sick note?

The case involves a cleaning worker employed by a cleaning services company, in a lawsuit decided by the Regional Labor Court of the 12th Region, in the state of Santa Catarina. The sector's collective agreement required employees' medical certificates to include the ICD code, on the grounds that the information was needed for eSocial (Brazil's digital payroll and labor reporting system) and for social security leave. The company admitted deducting the days on which the worker presented certificates without the code. She sought damages for invasion of privacy, and the regional court denied the claim. At the TST, the panel found the case legally significant (the threshold the TST requires before it reviews an appeal), because the court has rarely addressed the issue, but it kept the outcome: in the justices' view, collecting the health data is lawful, the employer becomes responsible for confidentiality, and the wrongful act lies in improper exposure or discriminatory use of the information, which was not proven.

The ruling is controversial because the decision itself acknowledges grounds to the contrary. The TST's Collective Disputes Section has precedents declaring invalid collective clauses that require the ICD code on medical certificates, as a violation of the privacy protected by article 5, X, of the Brazilian Constitution. Resolution 2,381/2024 of the Federal Council of Medicine (CFM), which governs medical documents, provides that physicians may include the diagnosis, coded or not, only for just cause, in compliance with a legal duty or at the patient's own request, and that such request must be expressly stated on the certificate. The ICD code is not among the mandatory items of a sick-leave certificate. The decision also notes that eSocial requires the ICD code only in the Workplace Accident Report, not in ordinary medical certificates, so the requirement is the employer's choice.

Then there is Brazil's General Data Protection Law (LGPD). Health data is sensitive personal data, and its processing is governed by article 11 of the LGPD, which sets out specific and narrower legal bases. The decision grounded the collection on article 7, which covers personal data in general and includes the controller's legitimate interest, a basis that does not exist in article 11 for sensitive data. This is one of the points likely to fuel the debate in future cases.

On the other hand, the ruling gives weight to the collective agreement, in line with Theme 1,046 of Brazil's Supreme Federal Court (STF). In June 2022, in ARE 1,121,633, reported by Justice Gilmar Mendes, the STF held that "collective agreements that, considering negotiated sector-specific suitability, agree on limitations or waivers of labor rights are constitutional, regardless of any specific statement of compensating advantages, provided that absolutely non-waivable rights are respected." The TST has been reaffirming this approach: on October 27, 2026, when it released the binding thesis of Theme 316, the full court upheld a negotiated 220 divisor for 40-hour workweeks expressly on the basis of Theme 1,046.

The open question is precisely the limit. In the reporting justice's opinion in Theme 1,046, the STF noted that collective clauses may not breach a minimum civilizational floor made up, among other elements, of constitutional norms. Privacy is a constitutional guarantee, which is why the Collective Disputes Section has been invalidating ICD clauses. Until this divergence is resolved, a clause on medical certificates may be upheld in an individual lawsuit and invalidated in a collective dispute.

For companies and unions, the conclusion is clear: collective bargaining carries weight, but it does not by itself settle the handling of health data. Anyone who keeps or intends to negotiate an ICD clause must ensure that the diagnosis stays within the medical department, never reaches supervisors and is never used to punish or discriminate, because that is where the duty to compensate recognized by the TST itself arises. For workers, it is worth knowing that, outside cases of just cause or legal duty, the physician includes the ICD code only at the patient's request, and that exposure of the diagnosis may give rise to compensation.

This content is for informational purposes only and does not replace the legal analysis of a specific case.

© 2026 Diego Amâncio Dias. Original text. Reproduction is permitted with credit to the source.

← All articles
Contact

Tell us about your operation in Brazil.

A first conversation covers the structure of your Brazilian workforce, the question in front of you and the timeline. Scope and fees are then confirmed in writing before any work begins.

Email
[email protected]
Phone and WhatsApp
+55 11 91090-1402
Languages
English, Portuguese, Spanish